My school does a literacy strategy called "Eyes Past Print with Voice Support" (EPP). We are told that research shows people need to read for 20 minutes a day in order to maintain their level of literacy. We are afraid many of our kids get far less than even that. In order to maintain them and also to model reading from (hopefully) fluent readers, each teacher reads to his or her students for a minimum of 5 minutes per class period, simultaneously providing the text for the students to read along. My instructional coach described the process in some detail here.I'm a math teacher. It's hard to find "math" reading that is interesting/engaging for anyone, let alone high schoolers who have a vested interest in demonstrating their boredom to you. What's not so hard: finding cool stuff that was written by people who had to use math when they did whatever it was they're writing about. Example:
Phil Plait, physicist, astronomer, and blogger, writes a blog for Discovery Magazine. A recent post, Two Moons Circling, offered and discussed an amateur astronomer's picture-set of one of Jupiter's moons passing in front of another from our Earthly vantage point. It truly is a remarkable series of pictures, with expert commentary by Dr. Plait. I found it because I follow Dr. Plait (BadAstronomer) on Twitter.
In my world, however, it takes more than just reading. Go read just the first paragraph of Two Moons Circling. I'll wait ... I guarantee you that first paragraph is enough to tune out 90% of high schoolers in any setting. The information is necessary to the story, but there are no explosions. Snooze.
So, I read the first paragraph quickly and then stopped. Then, I stepped into the middle of the room, right among the chairs. I told them to assume I was the sun and they were all planets and moons orbiting me. I admitted to them that I liked the idea of being the center of everything they've ever known. I showed them how the planets' and moons' orbits are not shaped like a sphere, but rather like a disk. I named a student and called him Jupiter. I named another two and called them Ganymede and Io. Through exaggerated hand movements, I demonstrated how the two rotate around the one, again on the same "disk." Then I read on.
The rest of the blog post discusses the interesting things to notice in the picture, then saves the best, perhaps most-relevant factoid for the end: the photos were taken from hundreds of millions of kilometers away (600 or so, actually). Yes, I had to convert that to miles for them. That's okay. I finish by telling the kids that if they want to see Jupiter for themselves, all they have to do is walk outside at night. At present, the giant planet is the brightest object in the Southeastern sky in the early evening. With a pair of binoculars, you can see the moons described in the blog post.
Why did this work? Because although the reading depended on math for its existence, it didn't write about math itself, which is -- frankly -- boring. Also because there was a picture to go along with the reading. Also because this is a subject I am passionate about. But finally because -- using the previous two becauses -- I succeeded at least a little bit in making it relevant to them. "You, you, and you are the planets and moons." "An amateur, like you, took these pictures." "You can go see these things for yourself."
Many of our teachers read from novels for their EPP, and more power to them. I don't think I can pull that off. I am a fluent reader, of course, but my passion is not novels. My passion is knowledge -- about the heavens, about our physical world, and about human nature. Sometimes, I figure out how to make those things about math, at least a little bit. Any chance I get to share that knowledge with these kids is a good day.
*Note: the photo above, credit NASA/JPL/University of Arizona, is not the photo described in the blog post, but does show the shadow of Jupiter's moon Europa passing over the gas giant. It's a pretty cool picture, too.
3 comments:
Great post Michae! I agree with everything you said, especially the novel vs. informational text. I think it's important to look at the data about reading. It's not that our students can't read (look at grade 4 and then grade 8 data). There is a disturbing pattern about reading scores as students progress through the 'system'. As the reading changes from learning to read to learning to interpret informational text American students begin to lag further and further behind. I applaud the efforts to read in content area classrooms, but if the reading isn't connected to the content and doesn't 'teach' students to read mathematically or scientifically then I would argue that the time may be used more effectively in other ways.
I encourage you to push your instrucitonal coach to think about what other mathematical texts you can bring into your reading. Have you thought about statistical analysis or paragraphs that include some description of data (any research article in the conclusions/results section- I also like to use these because it gets students thinking that they can read hard/rigorous/scholarly stuff), or 'read' a graph/diagram, or science article that pushes relationships between variables like a physics article or like you did with the orbits.
I will leave you with the thought that Algebra II is the one course that has statistical significance on success in college science coursework, and I believe the thought is that Algebra II has such a focus on not only equation/procedural fluency, but also graphical representation that it affects students being able to interpret scientific data, which is reading in math!
Read on! and thanks for sharing.
I haven't checked out your EPP yet but I wanted to mention that on this subject I think it is great to do what is your passion for EPP. If you're reading something that bores you, how can you expect students to get into it. Today we were converting miles to kilometers and Fahrenheit to Celsius and my students asked about why the US uses different units then nearly the rest of the world so I found this article and read it to them.
http://www.wisegeek.com/does-the-world-except-for-the-us-use-the-metric-system.htm
It was pretty fun because it was something they had asked so it was nice to do a reading on something that pertained to what we were doing and answered a question they had at the same time.
Thanks, Sarah. I turned right around and used the Metric information YOU provided in my next EPP, though with the benefit of time I added maps that showed exactly where Liberia and Myanmar are. My EPP's are turning out to be much more than just reading text!
Post a Comment